Feedback for students in the spring term of AY2009-10.

Thursday, April 29, 2010

A4 Grader Comments

The following (edited) comments from the grader may be useful.

  • Students showed their best efforts in summarizing various types of structural systems and were able to select the "best solution" using a set of logical procedures.
  • Every team was able to develop an extensive list of criteria to "grade" each plausible system.

The role of Numeric Decision Matrices

Ellen offered the following comments on decision matrices.  I’d note that you were not required to use a decision matrix on this assignment and did not lose points if you did not use one.  These comments are particularly useful for A6. [JEM]

If using a decision matrix avoid using any contradicting statements in the document such as the decision matrix shows one best alternative but another is proposed in the recommendation.

Teamwork

  • All students have worked well with their teammates.

No comments:

Post a Comment